Accessibility Links


  • 1h 35m
  • Alon Schwarz
  • Israel
  • 2022

For every story there are two sides but evidence will reveal the truth.

The tape-recorded words “erase it” take on new weight in the context of history and war. When the State of Israel was established in 1948, war broke out and hundreds of Palestinian villages were depopulated in its aftermath. Israelis know this as the War of Independence. Palestinian call it “Al Nakba” (the Catastrophe).

In the late 1990s, graduate student Teddy Katz conducted research into a large-scale massacre that had allegedly occurred in the village of Tantura in 1948. His work later came under attack and his reputation was ruined, but 140 hours of audio testimonies remain.

Doc Edge alumni director Alon Schwarz revisits Palestinian residents and former Israeli soldiers of the Alexandroni Brigade in an effort to re-examine what happened in Tantura and explore why the Nakba is taboo in Israeli society. The now elderly ex-soldiers recall unsettling acts of war while disquietly pausing at points they either don’t remember or won’t speak of. Audio from Katz’s 20-year-old interviews cuts through the silence of self-preservation and exposes how power, silencing, and protected narratives can sculpt history.


Click here for in-theatre tickets.

Category “True or False” presented by LUMO


Alon Schwarz


Shaul Schwarz


Maiken Baird


Alon Schwarz


Arabic, English, Hebrew



You may also like

True or False Features Pass (7 Films)
The Bowraville Murders
  • 1h 27m
  • Allan Clarke
  • Australia
  • 2021
Eternal Spring
  • 1h 26m
  • Jason Loftus
  • Canada
  • 2022
Singing In The Wilderness
  • 1h 38m
  • Dongnan Chen
  • China
  • 2021
Speer Goes to Hollywood
  • 1h 38m
  • Vanessa Lapa
  • Israel, Austria, Germany
  • 2021
Unseen Skies
  • 1h 38m
  • Yaara Bou Melhem
  • United States, Australia
  • 2021

Download the app to view your purchased content!